12 questions to ask an AI education vendor before a pilot
Short answer: before a pilot, ask every AI vendor the same twelve questions, covering data and model training, student information, export and deletion, subprocessors, what administrators can see about teachers, and whether the product ever says where AI should not be used. A vendor who answers in writing, specifically, and before the sales call, is telling you something.
Data and training
- Can anything we upload be used to train a model, by you or by the model provider? On whose terms, and can we see them?
- Which model providers do you use, and on which tier of their service?
- Who are your subprocessors, what does each one see, and where are they located?
Student information
- Does the product need student accounts or student data at all? If so, why?
- Are uploads checked for student information before they are stored, and does that check avoid copying what it finds?
- Can a learner profile or support plan hold a name, diagnosis or score? Should it?
Control and exit
- Can we export everything we own as readable files, at any time, without asking?
- When we leave, is our data erased, and do we get a record of what was destroyed and when?
- Is there a schedule of every category of data the system holds, and how is it kept accurate?
Teachers and classrooms
- What can our administrators see about individual teachers' activity? (A usage list is one step from a list of who gets judged.)
- Does a teacher approve everything before it reaches a class, or can the product act on its own?
- Does the product ever recommend not using AI for an activity, and say why?
Compound Intellect's answers
Briefly: nothing uploaded trains a model (model calls use a paid tier whose terms forbid it); there are no student accounts; uploads are checked before they are stored and the check reports counts, not the matched text; learner profiles refuse names, diagnoses and scores; everything can be exported, and erasure comes with a certificate; the schedule of data is generated from the code; administrators see nothing about individual teachers; three teacher approvals cannot be skipped; and every AI-free activity names who decided it. Details are on the Trust page, and the compliance pack is sent on request with no NDA.
Related: AI rollout for school and district leaders
Questions schools ask
- What should schools ask before buying an AI tool?
- Whether uploads can train a model, which providers and subprocessors see the data, whether student data is needed, how export and deletion work, what admins can see about teachers, and whether teachers approve everything first.
- Does Compound Intellect use school documents to train AI?
- No. Model calls use a paid tier whose terms forbid training on submitted content.
- Does Compound Intellect need student data?
- No. It has no student accounts, and learner profiles refuse names, diagnoses and scores.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com