The AI Assessment Scale and the four classroom decisions: how they fit together
Short answer: the AI Assessment Scale (AIAS), by Mike Perkins, Jasper Roe and Leon Furze, is a five-level framework for how much AI an assessment allows, from No AI to AI Exploration. Compound Intellect's four decisions (Teach with AI, Teach about AI, Teacher-use only, AI-free) plan every activity in a term under the school's policy, including work that is not assessed. Use the AIAS to set the level for an assessed task, and the four decisions to plan the whole course around it.
The AI Assessment Scale in brief
The revised scale, described in The AI Assessment Scale Revisited (December 2024), has five levels:
- No AI: the assessment is completed without AI, relying on the student's own knowledge and skills.
- AI-assisted planning: AI may support brainstorming and early planning.
- AI-assisted task completion: AI may help with drafting and editing, with the emphasis on critical evaluation and the student's own voice.
- Full AI: students direct AI tools to meet the learning outcomes while showing critical thinking and subject knowledge.
- AI exploration: students and educators use AI creatively to find new ways of meeting outcomes.
It is widely used and well regarded. For the authors' own account, read Leon Furze's post on the update.
Where the two differ
| AI Assessment Scale | Four decisions | |
|---|---|---|
| What it decides | How much AI an assessment allows | What role AI plays in each activity |
| Scope | One assessment task | Every activity in a term, assessed or not |
| Teacher's own AI use | Not its focus | Its own decision: Teacher-use only |
| AI as object of study | Can appear at higher levels | Its own decision: Teach about AI |
| Who decided | Set by the educator | Every AI-free activity names its authority: policy, curriculum or recommendation |
Using them together
An activity planned as AI-free corresponds to AIAS Level 1. An assessed activity planned as Teach with AI can carry the AIAS level that fits it, for example Level 2 when AI supports planning only. Recording both gives students one clear rule for the task and gives leaders a term-wide picture of where AI is used, studied, kept to the teacher, or kept out.
Related: The four ways to use AI in a classroom · Protecting assessment from AI
Questions schools ask
- What is the AI Assessment Scale?
- A five-level framework by Mike Perkins, Jasper Roe and Leon Furze for how much AI an assessment allows: No AI, AI-assisted planning, AI-assisted task completion, Full AI, and AI exploration.
- Is Compound Intellect a replacement for the AI Assessment Scale?
- No. The AIAS sets the AI level for an assessment. Compound Intellect plans every activity in a term, and an assessed activity can carry its AIAS level alongside its decision.
- Which AIAS level matches an AI-free activity?
- Level 1, No AI.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com