The four ways to use AI in a classroom
Short answer: every activity in a course can be given one of four AI decisions. Teach with AI: students use an approved AI process to practise the subject, with an independent check. Teach about AI: the AI's output is the object of study, so students learn how it works and fails. Teacher-use only: AI helps the teacher prepare, and students never use it. AI-free: AI is kept out on purpose, to protect independent mastery or assessment.
Why four decisions, and why per activity
"Should we use AI in this unit?" is the wrong question, because one unit holds very different kinds of work. An investigation the student must carry out themselves, a practice task where AI feedback helps, and the teacher's own preparation can all sit in the same week. Giving each activity one of four decisions makes the plan precise enough to teach from and to defend.
1. Teach with AI
What it is: students use AI to practise the subject, on a task the teacher set, inside boundaries, with an independent check on what the AI said.
Choose it when AI makes practice better without replacing the thinking being learned: getting feedback on a draft the student already wrote, testing an argument they already hold, or finding the gaps in a design they drafted first.
Example (Biology 10): students draft their own controls for an osmosis investigation first, then ask the AI only for uncontrolled variables they missed.
2. Teach about AI
What it is: the AI's output is the thing students examine. They learn how it works and how it fails: hallucination, bias, sourcing and attribution.
Choose it when students can check the AI against something they know or saw, so its mistakes become the lesson.
Example: students audit an AI-written explanation of a mechanism and check it against what they observed in their own practical.
3. Teacher-use only
What it is: AI helps the teacher plan, differentiate, write worked examples or draft feedback. Students do not use it, and it is never applied to student work in front of the class.
Choose it when the time saved goes back into teaching, and when the unit is AI-free for students but the teacher's preparation need not be.
Example: generating differentiated scaffolds before a lesson.
4. AI-free
What it is: AI is deliberately excluded, and the plan says who decided it: the school's policy, the curriculum, or a recommendation the teacher accepted.
Choose it when the student's own unaided work is what is being learned or measured: summative assessment, the practical a unit is built on, closed-book tests.
Example: the final practical report, individually assessed, where the school's policy prohibits AI in summative work.
The four side by side
| Decision | Who uses AI | Purpose | Typical activity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teach with AI | Students, with boundaries | Practise the subject | Feedback on an own draft |
| Teach about AI | Students, as critics | Learn how AI works and fails | Fact-check an AI explanation |
| Teacher-use only | The teacher | Prepare and differentiate | Scaffolds, worked examples |
| AI-free | Nobody | Protect mastery and assessment | Assessed write-up, closed-book test |
Related: Where AI should not be used in a course · How to turn a school AI policy into classroom practice
Questions schools ask
- What is the difference between teaching with AI and teaching about AI?
- Teaching with AI uses it as a tool for practising the subject. Teaching about AI makes its output the object of study, so students learn how it works and where it goes wrong.
- Can a unit mix all four?
- Yes, and most do. One Biology unit in Compound Intellect's test course holds all four: a guided AI activity, an AI-literacy activity, a teacher-preparation task and two AI-free activities.
- Is teacher-use only allowed in an AI-free unit?
- Under the Compound Intellect Standard, yes: teachers may use AI to prepare material for a unit that is AI-free for students. A school's own policy may say otherwise, and that policy wins.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com