AI feedback on student writing: how to use it without replacing the writing
Short answer: AI feedback helps only after the student has written their own draft. Set the order: the student drafts, AI gives feedback, the student decides what to change and says so in one line. Keep assessed and timed writing AI-free where the school's policy says so, and never let AI write the draft.
The order matters
- Draft first, unaided. The thinking happens here.
- Ask for feedback, not rewriting. "Where is my argument weakest?" not "Improve this."
- Student decides. They accept, reject or adapt each point.
- Disclose. One line: “I used [tool] to [what]. I [what I did with it].”
The Compound Intellect Standard permits exactly this: students may use AI to generate feedback on their own draft after they have produced that draft themselves.
Good feedback requests
- Which claim in my essay has the least evidence?
- What is the strongest objection to my argument?
- Where does my explanation skip a step?
- Which paragraph is least clear, and why? (Don't rewrite it.)
Where it does not belong
- Assessed essays and coursework, where policy prohibits AI in summative work.
- Timed and exam-style writing.
- The first draft.
Related: AI in an English course · Student AI disclosure statement
Questions schools ask
- Is it OK for students to get AI feedback on their writing?
- Yes, after they have written the draft themselves and outside assessed work where policy prohibits it. They should decide what to change and disclose it.
- How should students ask AI for feedback?
- Ask for feedback, not rewriting: where is the argument weakest, which claim lacks evidence, where does an explanation skip a step.
- Should teachers use AI to grade writing?
- Compound Intellect does not do automated grading, by design. Assessment judgement stays with the teacher who knows the student.
Try it on one course, for one term.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com