Where AI should and should not be used in an English course
Short answer: In English, keep AI out of assessed essays, timed writing and the first draft where students find their own argument. Use it to argue against a thesis the student already holds, give feedback on a draft they wrote, and as a text whose style and claims students critique.
Keep AI out of
- Assessed essays and coursework. The writing is the evidence, and policy usually prohibits AI in summative work.
- Timed and exam-style writing. Students need to perform unaided.
- The first draft. Finding an argument in your own words is the skill; AI drafting skips it.
Use AI on purpose for
- Argue against my thesis (Teach with AI). students test a position they already hold and answer the strongest objection.
- Feedback on an own draft (Teach with AI). after the student has written it, under the school's disclosure rule.
- Critique an AI essay (Teach about AI). students mark an AI-written response for generic claims, missing evidence and voice.
- Model answers and differentiated texts (Teacher-use only). prepared and checked by the teacher.
Decide per activity, and say who decided
Writing is where AI's fluency is most tempting and most damaging to learning, so the line between drafting and feedback matters most here. Whatever the subject, give each activity one of four decisions, and record whether an AI-free boundary comes from the school's policy, the curriculum, or the teacher's judgment. For a fully worked example from a real course, see AI in a science course.
Related: Protecting assessment from AI · Student AI disclosure statement
Questions schools ask
- Should students use AI to write essays?
- Not for assessed essays or the first draft. AI can help afterwards with feedback on a draft the student wrote, or by arguing against their thesis.
- How can English teachers use AI in lessons?
- Have students critique an AI-written essay for generic claims and missing evidence, or use it to test an argument they already hold.
- How do students disclose AI use in English?
- With one line: I used [tool] to [what]. I [what I did with it].
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com