Where AI should and should not be used in a maths course
Short answer: In maths, keep AI out of fluency practice students must do themselves, timed and closed-book tests, and assessed problem solving. Use it to generate varied practice, explain a worked solution after an attempt, and as a flawed solution for students to correct.
Keep AI out of
- Fluency practice. Procedures students need to own, such as arithmetic, algebraic manipulation and standard methods.
- Tests and assessed problem solving. Where the working is the evidence, and where most school policies prohibit AI in summative work.
- First attempts at a new problem type. Struggle is part of learning the method; AI help too early removes it.
Use AI on purpose for
- Correct a flawed solution (Teach about AI). students find and fix the error in an AI-worked solution.
- Explain after an attempt (Teach with AI). students ask for an explanation only after showing their own working.
- Varied practice sets and worked examples (Teacher-use only). the teacher generates and checks them before use.
Decide per activity, and say who decided
AI tools can make arithmetic and reasoning errors, which is a hazard in practice and an opportunity for Teach about AI. Whatever the subject, give each activity one of four decisions, and record whether an AI-free boundary comes from the school's policy, the curriculum, or the teacher's judgment. For a fully worked example from a real course, see AI in a science course.
Related: Protecting assessment from AI · Student AI disclosure statement
Questions schools ask
- Should students use AI for maths homework?
- Not for practice of methods they need to own. AI can help after an honest attempt, by explaining a solution, or as a flawed solution for students to correct.
- Can AI make mistakes in maths?
- Yes. AI tools can make arithmetic and reasoning errors, which is why checking an AI-worked solution is a useful activity.
- How can maths teachers use AI?
- For preparation: varied practice sets, worked examples and differentiated questions, checked before use.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com