How to turn a school AI policy into classroom practice
Short answer: read each course's real activities against the policy, and decide for every activity whether students use AI, learn about AI, whether only the teacher uses it, or whether it stays AI-free. Record which authority decided each exclusion (the policy, the curriculum, or a recommendation), have the teacher verify and approve the result, and teach from that plan for a term.
Why policies stall between the office and the classroom
Most school AI policies are written at the level of the whole school: approved tools, age limits, consent, what counts as misuse in assessed work. Teaching does not happen at that level. It happens in a specific unit of a specific course, with a specific teacher deciding what students do on Tuesday.
When nothing connects the two, every teacher reads the policy alone and invents their own rules. Students in the same building then meet different rules in different rooms, and the policy that was meant to create consistency produces the opposite.
Five steps from policy to practice
1. Start from the documents that already exist
The department has already done the intellectual work: schemes of work, unit plans, practicals, assessment calendars. Start there rather than from a blank template. If the school has not written an AI policy yet, use a published default and adapt it later; a department should not be blocked waiting on a committee. Compound Intellect ships one, the Compound Intellect Standard, for exactly this reason.
2. Have the teacher check what was read
Before anything is proposed, the teacher who wrote the course confirms that the units, hours and assessments were read correctly. A plan built on a guess at the curriculum is worth nothing; a plan built on the teacher's correction of it is worth the term. In Compound Intellect this check takes about twenty-five minutes and cannot be skipped.
3. Decide at the level of the activity, not the unit
A unit is too large to answer for. One unit can hold a protected assessment, a guided AI activity and a teacher-preparation task at the same time. Give each activity one of four decisions:
- Teach with AIStudents use an approved process to practise the subject, with boundaries and an independent check.
- Teach about AIStudents learn how it works and how it fails: hallucination, bias, sourcing, attribution.
- Teacher-use onlyIt helps the teacher plan, differentiate or prepare. Students do not use it.
- AI-freeDeliberately excluded to protect independent mastery or assessment integrity.
4. Name who decided every exclusion
Where AI is kept out, write down why, and on whose authority: the school's policy, the curriculum or exam specification, or a recommendation the teacher accepted. That turns "no AI here" from a teacher's personal preference into a boundary a head of department can defend to a parent or governor.
5. Approve a version, teach it, and review at the end of term
The teacher includes, holds or leaves out each activity, then approves the plan as a version. Until then it is only a proposal. Teach from it for a term and look at what actually got used. If nothing gets taught twice, it did not work.
A worked example: one Biology unit
This is from Biology 10, the real course Compound Intellect is tested against. The unit is Cell Structure and Transport, and the school's policy prohibits AI in summative work.
| Activity | Decision | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Critique an investigation design | Teach with AI | Students draft their own controls first, then ask the AI for uncontrolled variables only. |
| Carry out the osmosis investigation | AI-free | The observation is the evidence base for the whole unit. Authority: curriculum. |
| Generate differentiated scaffolds | Teacher-use only | Preparation. Never in front of the class, never on student work. |
| Audit a mechanism explanation | Teach about AI | The AI's output is the object of study, checked against what students saw. |
| Final practical report | AI-free | Individually assessed. The school's policy prohibits AI in summative work. Authority: school policy. |
The same unit carries two AI-free activities, one guided AI activity, one AI-literacy activity and one preparation task. Asking "is this unit an AI unit?" would have got every one of them wrong.
Related: The AI Assessment Scale and the four decisions · School AI policy checklist · A free AI policy for schools · Where AI should not be used in a course · AI rollout for school and district leaders
Questions schools ask
- What should a school AI policy include before it can be put into practice?
- At minimum: approved tools, minimum age and parental consent, devices, permitted and prohibited uses, the disclosure wording students use when they used AI, and the assessment windows where AI is not allowed. Those are the fields the Compound Intellect administrator console asks for.
- What if our school does not have an AI policy yet?
- Start with a published default and change it once your own is written. Compound Intellect includes one, the Compound Intellect Standard, so a department can begin before a policy committee finishes.
- Who makes the final decision about AI in a lesson?
- The teacher. Compound Intellect proposes, and the teacher verifies the reading of their course, chooses what belongs this term and approves a version. There is no setting that removes those three steps.
- How long does it take a teacher?
- About forty-five minutes for one course and one term: roughly twenty-five minutes checking the course was read correctly and twenty minutes choosing which activities belong this term.
The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.
Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com