Compound Intellect
Home → Guides → Where AI should not be used

Where should AI not be used in a course?

By Basharat Ali, founder of Compound Intellect ·

Short answer: keep AI out wherever the student's own unaided work is the thing being learned or measured. In practice that usually means individually assessed work your school's policy covers, the practical or first-hand observation a unit is built on, and closed-book tests. Decide it activity by activity, and record whether the boundary comes from the school's policy, the curriculum, or a recommendation the teacher accepted.

The test: is the student's own work the evidence?

An activity should be AI-free when its value depends on the student doing it unaided. If the point of an investigation is that students observe something themselves, an AI summary of what they would have seen replaces the learning. If a write-up is assessed individually, AI help makes the grade describe something other than the student.

Not everything near an assessment needs to be AI-free. A student can use AI to critique an investigation design before carrying out the investigation themselves. The decision belongs to the activity, not to the unit or the subject.

Where the line usually falls

Name the authority for every boundary

"No AI here" is much easier to hold when everyone can see who decided it. Compound Intellect attaches one of three authorities to every AI-free activity:

The distinction matters when a parent, student or colleague pushes back. A policy boundary is not the teacher's to relax; a recommendation is.

AI-free work is not a gap

In a plan, AI-free weeks are often drawn as empty space, as if nothing had been decided. They are the opposite: protected work, chosen on purpose. In the Biology 10 course Compound Intellect is tested against, three AI-free components across the term carry an authority each:

AI-free componentAuthority
Osmosis investigationCurriculum
Assessed write-upSchool policy
Closed-book testSchool policy

Around them, the same course still uses AI where it helps: generating starter questions, comparing explanations, surfacing misconceptions and organising evidence.

Related: AI in maths · AI in English · AI in history · Protecting assessment from AI · AI in a science course · How to turn a school AI policy into classroom practice · What Compound Intellect will not build

Questions schools ask

Should AI be banned from homework?
Not as a blanket rule. Decide per activity: if the homework is the student's own evidence of learning or is assessed, keep it AI-free; if it is practice where an approved AI process with an independent check helps, it can be a Teach with AI activity.
Is it the teacher or the school who decides where AI is not allowed?
Both, and the plan should say which. Some boundaries come from the school's policy and are not the teacher's to relax. Others come from the curriculum, and some are recommendations the teacher accepted. Compound Intellect records the authority for each one.
Does Compound Intellect detect AI use in student work?
No. It does not do AI detection or plagiarism scoring, by design: it will not sell a number that accuses a student. It plans where AI belongs before the work is set.
Try it on one course, for one term.

The pilot is one department, one term, free and with no card. You keep every plan, package and resource whatever you decide afterwards.

Talk about a pilotbasharat@compound-intellect.com